I promised an update on the post I wrote on January 21, 2011 regarding reporting a closed business to Google Places via their report a problem link.
Approximately 1 month later (Feb 19 to be exact) I received the following response from Google via email:
Thanks again for sharing your local expertise with other Google users! We
have reviewed Bellwether because of your report.
If there is still anything wrong in our information about Bellwether on
Google Maps http://maps.google.com/maps/place?cid=4011163203453493749,
please consider updating it directly via the “edit” link, or reporting
Thanks for your help,
The Google Maps team
If you click the link I’ve made live in the above message from Google, you will see that this rural gift shop’s Place Page now bears the message: This Place Is Permanently Closed.
I was glad to receive a timely response from Google – I think 4 weeks is really pretty good. However, the ‘permanently closed’ snippet doesn’t fully resolve the problem.
– I can still find this page if I search Google Maps for the business name and location.
– Because this listing still exists, what will happen when the NEW business that is moving into the old business’ location tries to create and claim a Place Page for that business? Will they be denied the ability to do this because the address is identical to that of a closed business? Will their data, if published, merge with that of the old gift shop so that phone numbers, reviews, citations or other data gets blended?
I’m not sure how all of this will pan out, and while it’s good that the ‘closed’ message will potentially keep travelers from going to this town to visit this out-of-the-way business, I am very curious about what will happen if the restaurant that plans to open in the building will run into problems.
Anyway, I wanted to keep my promise of reporting how long it took to get a response from Google about this, and for the record, it took about a month. Ah, the ins-and-outs of Local. They keep us on our toes.
But today I read something in the Google Places Help Forum that has me whistling a tune with a slightly different tone.
The thread began as the all-too-common discussion of why a business may not use a P.O. Box as its address and why many accounts are now being offered the postcard-only verification option, but then user, Barbara7, left the following comment that I found to be of definite interest:
Well thank you for that Google. You know, it seems the more I use Google the less friendly it becomes.
There are at least two areas in the US that I know of where the United States Postal Services no longer delivers mail to the street (business) address. Many residents and businesses in towns and villages on the east end of Long Island are required to have a PO Box in addition to their resident or business address. The PO box is the only place where the USPS will deliver mail. My business is out this way. The other one I know of is in towns near Vail, CO. I’m certain that there are many other places in the US where the USPS has stopped delivering mail, except to PO boxes.
So I too have a legitimate business that Google does not want to know about, and provides no other means of verification. Thanks again, Google. I’ll be buying those $25/mo tags you keep pushing at me right away. . . just as soon as you allow me to verify my business.
And now I find that Google’s own algorithms favor businesses with a Places account. Thanks again, Google. You’re getting more and more Micro$ofty everyday.
If Barbara7 is correct, and there is a growing trend of the post office not delivering mail directly to homes and businesses, then we do indeed have a problem (or, rather, Google does). To pin a scenario on this, let’s say you’re an accountant with a home office on Long Island or a Personal Trainer with a studio in a small downtown section outside of Vail, and while your business meets Google’s Quality Guidelines of having in-person transactions with customers, you can’t get mail at your home, office or shop because the post office doesn’t deliver it there. You are required to pick up your mail at your P.O. Box, and sadly, that puts you out of the Local game, as defined by Google.
I’ve lived in and visited numerous towns where everyone comes down to a central post office to pick up the mail, but until reading Barbara7’s comment, I had yet to consider the ramifications of this for all those doing business locally in these kinds of communities.
What should Google do? I’d say it’s up to them to get communication going with the post office to discover which areas of the country (and the world?) are no longer being served directly by Mr. Postman. These communities then, should receive a special dispensation, Vatican-style, so that the businesses operating there can use a P.O. Box in their profiles.
Too hard to carry out a plan like this? Let it be remembered that nobody twisted Google’s long arm to get them to set themselves up as Local Search authorities. I would say that what came up today in the help forum poses an exciting challenge for Google engineers to surmount, so that all legitimate local businesses are receiving fair treatment. They definitely have the staff and brains to accomplish a manual fix like this in the system so that submissions in given parts of given locations are given special treatment. Until then, the guidelines are definitely discriminatory. Wouldn’t you say?